How to compete on utility transmission planning – EY – US

utility transmission planning

By focusing on execution playbooks and standardized modules, utilities can enhance project prioritization based on speed-to-energization. Future-oriented utilities utilize interactive hosting-capacity maps and decision-support dashboards to align planning with economic development. Traditional design focuses on functional specifications, treating costs and value as secondary.

Over time, these utilities set the pace, while slower competitors face less favorable conditions. This proactive approach enhances credibility and execution discipline, drawing hyperscale demand and strengthening relationships with regulators and investors. Large-load customers, policymakers and vendors view these commitments as proof that a utility can operate faster and more reliably than cautious peers.

Grid-enhancing technologies (GETs) can increase the capacity of existing transmission infrastructure faster and at lower cost than building new infrastructure. From highly detailed power flows to contingency and stability analysis, to national-scale planning studies, NLR advances understanding of the role and value of transmission in future power systems. In 2021, FERC and the National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners established the Joint Federal-State Task Force on Electric Transmission, which aims to bridge the gap between federal and state policymaking on transmission. A proactive approach requires ISOs and RTOs to take a long view on what lines will be most beneficial to the system in the future. The Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) has a broad oversight role that has guided transmission planning policy over the past decades. An insufficient transmission network can lead to inefficient use of generation resources or a slower transition to low-cost technologies.

Focus on speed to permit

This approach reduces engineering time, yields predictable costs and supports long-term engineering and procurement alliances, transforming design into a strategic advantage for operational efficiency. As part of the NTP Study, NLR and Pacific Northwest National Laboratory conducted a qualitative assessment of obstacles to interregional transmission, a high-level survey of potential opportunities to overcome those challenges, and which system actors or organizations are best equipped to lead each solution. Despite the potential for significant benefits of interregional transmission, there are a variety of barriers to developing these types of transmission projects in the United States. NLR researchers use leading modeling and analysis tools to measure the real benefits GETs can deliver to a given system and to help grid operators and public utility commissions decide where and when to deploy them. The resulting data, analysis, and insights enable stakeholders to make informed decisions about the future of regional and interregional transmission. Among other improvements, the order required accounting for how public policy impacts transmission needs and including provisions for how costs of new lines would be shared by those who benefit from the addition of new lines.

A few years ago, a consortium of transmission owners established a pooled transformer reserve, cutting replacement lead time from 24 months to under 10 weeks, creating a unique supplier network. This anticipatory planning allows for swift responses to customer requests, turning foresight into speed and economic advantage. By translating forecasts into early regulatory positioning — such as filing preliminary corridor applications and securing necessary sites — they gain a competitive edge.

This shift transforms planning from a compliance-driven process into a race for speed and leadership. Transmission planners in the U.S. can leverage these tools to support their planning processes. Each chapter of the final report for the National Transmission Planning Study is available to download as a separate PDF.

Of course, long-term transmission planning is a complex task that requires data, modeling, and impact assessments. While transmission providers have been largely successful in identifying lines needed to maintain system reliability, there has been limited success in identifying lines that could provide other benefits. This work helps to identify investment needs but does not direct funding to projects or mandate that certain transmission lines be built. This explainer discusses the nuts and bolts of the transmission planning process, who is involved, and the latest policy developments. Transmission lines, which deliver power from power plants to electricity distribution networks (see Electricity 101), are an essential component of the electricity grid. This explainer discusses the nuts and bolts of transmission planning, relevant actors, and recent policy developments.

utility transmission planning

The repeal of standards for light-duty vehicles and power plants will increase air pollution that contributes to death and disease, adding to the already substantial forgone climate-related benefits of these regulations by about $780 billion. The task force convenes to discuss a variety of transmission issues, including transmission planning and navigating the overlap in federal-state regulatory processes. For example, PJM, a multi-state RTO in the Northeast, is actively modifying its transmission planning process to include more analysis on anticipated future changes- like the evolving generation mix and increasing electrification. In order to meet future demands on the electric grid, experts believe a broader and more proactive planning approach is needed. For example, FERC Order 1000, passed in 2010, directed transmission providers to upgrade their regional planning approaches https://forestwildwood.com/articles/seed-ticks-impact-management/ to improve transmission planning. RTOs and independent system operators (ISOs), which are different types of organizations that operate the grid but do not own power lines, power plants, and other resources, identify new transmission needs in their territories.

utility transmission planning

Transmission Scenarios

  • Transmission investment has the potential to increase reliability, lower electricity prices, and lower emissions.
  • Transmission infrastructure, or lack thereof, has the ability to make or break opportunities for new and existing power plants.
  • Digital twins are transforming the utilities sector by enhancing efficiency and resilience.
  • But transmission lines take a long time to approve and build (see Transmission 102), and their value depends largely on the types of power plants in the area and electricity demand on the other end of the line.
  • This shift compresses scale, speed and capital intensity, allowing utilities to evolve beyond traditional energy providers.

By presenting shovel-ready projects to regulators, they establish themselves as reliable partners, while slower competitors risk being perceived as speculative and vulnerable to cancellations. By sharing queue maps, load projections and capacity plans, they build credibility with hyperscalers and policymakers, attracting significant load to their corridors. By using high-voltage line families, modular substations and pre-approved templates, they streamline design cycles and simplify procurement.

utility transmission planning

Digital twins are transforming the utilities sector by enhancing efficiency and resilience. Utilities that view transmission planning as a competitive instrument rather than a compliance burden will thrive. This shift compresses scale, speed and capital intensity, allowing utilities to evolve beyond traditional energy providers. Utilities are facing unprecedented opportunities for growth driven by hyperscale data centers and advanced manufacturing. This strategic approach improves their ability https://helm-engine.org/tag/energy-consumption to attract and energize large-load customers efficiently. Leaders invest in comprehensive capabilities across areas like demand forecasting, siting intelligence and real estate mapping.

Learn more about the National Transmission Planning Study in a new Lab Notes episode of NLR's Peaks to Power podcast. NLR also identified transformative actions that could be applied to all regions to increase the value of interregional transmission. To download the data, visit the National Transmission Planning Study OpenEI page. The NTP Study modeled and analyzed nearly 100 future transmission scenarios with a range of economic, reliability, and resilience conditions. Additionally, the team developed national grid-scale planning tools and practices necessary to address those interregional transmission needs. During the study (2022–2024), the team conducted extensive stakeholder engagement and developed a novel approach that links long- and short-term power systems models.

Real Time Grid Reliability Management The real time grid reliability management area develops operational decision support tools, as well as visualization and monitoring software programs with data from the SCADA and EMS systems, and increasingly from the next generation Wide Area Measurement Systems (WAMS). Reliability and Markets Efforts within the reliability and markets area focus on developing a comprehensive set of integrated market/engineering design principles, tools, and technologies to support efficient and competitive electricity markets. Together, the suite of strategies can help improve the efficiency and efficacy of today's transmission system, increase grid reliability, and lead to cost savings that are then passed onto customers. Multiple analyses posit that long-term planning based on multiple potential future scenarios that accounts for a wide variety of benefits could find more efficient solutions to congestion, reliability and new generation needs relative to more reactive transmission planning strategies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *